[ad_1]
Jury instructions continue
The judge continues to give instructions to the jury.
Final argument has ended
The final argument in this case has concluded. The judge will now give instructions to the jury.
Carroll’s lawyer calls on Trump campaign to launch rebuttal
Mr. Carroll’s lawyer, Sean Crowley, rose after the defense’s closing argument and responded by pointing out the demeanor of Mr. Trump and his lawyers in court.
“I’m going to follow the rules of this court, but Mr. Trump and his lawyers don’t seem to know what to do,” Crowley said.
Mr. Crowley went on to say that the defense was “completely misrepresenting the facts.”
”[Trump] He lied and slandered her over and over again and it was proven, he did those things and his lawyer is saying it’s her fault,” Crowley said.
Haba and judge clash over freedom of speech
After Kaplan interrupted one of Haba’s statements to the jury, she said, “In our country, you have a right to speak.” The judge replied, “You have a constitutional right to some kinds of speech, but not others.”
Defamation is considered an exception to First Amendment protection.
President Trump’s lawyer Haba concludes argument
Mr. Haba concluded the defense’s closing argument.
President Trump joins Truth Social outside court during closing argument
After leaving court early this morning and as the defense began its closing arguments, Trump posted 20 times to his Truth Social account.
The posts include articles that President Trump apparently wanted included in the trial, highlighting negative allegations against Carroll.
Trump also called Kaplan a “Clinton-appointed” judge whose “absolute hatred for Donald J. Trump (me!) has kept me from seeing clearly until now.” He also posted a critical post.
The former president claimed that his name recognition was so high that he “couldn’t do anything unless it was on Page Six.”
“I’ve been considered an A-list celebrity for decades, but the woman who made the accusation can’t tell you the day, month, season, year, or decade, so I don’t want to mention any dates.” No one knows if they should,” Trump added.
Trump continued to call the trial a “sham,” arguing that the defense was unable to include everything it wanted in evidence.
The judge repeatedly reminded Mr. Trump and his lawyers that the factual issues that Mr. Trump continues to dispute were decided by the trial court.
Judge tells Trump’s lawyer: ‘You won’t fight me’
When Haba continued to imply that Carroll had lied about the assault for fame, the judge responded, “The fact that Mr. Trump sexually assaulted Ms. Carroll is established.” When her girlfriend, Haba, pushed back, the judge reprimanded her: “You don’t fight with me.”
Defense claims President Trump cannot control social media users’ ‘free speech’
In his closing argument, Haba continued to shift blame away from Trump, pointing instead to social media users who tweeted threats and harmful messages against Carroll.
Haba said that since there was a five-hour gap between Trump’s first statement against Carroll, users had already posted tweets calling him a liar, and Carroll had received those messages. He insisted that it was not Trump’s fault.
“He did it not because he wanted them to, but because they didn’t believe her story and thought she was a liar,” Haba said.
“This is the beauty of free speech in America,” Haba added. “He can control social media users as much as he can control the weather.”
Judge disagrees with Haba, who denies assaulting and insulting Carroll.
Haba’s closure got off to a tough start after Kaplan twice opposed her and warned that further violations of the order would have “consequences.”
The first rebuttal was when Hubba claimed that Trump continued to deny the assault even after his conviction because it was “the truth,” and the second was when Carroll’s account posted a message that read “More than Swiss cheese. “There’s a hole,” she said. his warning.
Defense begins closing arguments
Trump’s lawyer, Haba, began the defense’s closing argument.
President Trump returns to court to close defense
President Trump returned to court for the defense’s closing arguments. He left during closing arguments by Carroll’s attorney.
The court takes a 10-minute break before the defense’s closing argument.
The court adjourned for 10 minutes. After the return, Trump’s lawyers are expected to make closing arguments.
Carroll’s lawyer uses his claim that Mar-a-Lago is worth $1.5 billion to justify damages
Carroll’s lawyers cited President Trump’s claims that the Florida resort is worth billions of dollars to explain the proposed damages she is seeking.
He said Trump is “a very wealthy man,” adding that he is personally worth $10 billion, that Mar-a-Lago is worth $1.5 billion and that he owns the Doral estate. He noted that the company said it was worth $2.5 billion.
Defense attorneys challenged that part of her argument, but it was rejected.
During Mr. Trump’s civil fraud trial, he repeatedly presented similar numbers to defend himself against claims by New York Attorney General Letitia James that he had inflated the value of his net worth and assets.
Trump’s lawyer opposes damages proposal
In the end, Carroll’s lawyers offered an estimate of damages of about $7 million to $12 million, based on a model created by Northwestern University professor Ashley Humphries. Mr. Haba disputed those figures, but Mr. Kaplan rejected them, instructing jurors to be “arbiters of fact.”
Humphries was also an expert witness in Rudy Giuliani’s defamation trial, in which he was ordered to pay $148 million to two former Georgia election officials.
Carroll’s lawyer: President Trump thinks ‘the rules don’t apply to me’
Carroll’s lawyer, Roberta Kaplan, who is not related to the judge, told jurors that Trump is a liar who thinks “the rules don’t apply to him.”
“MS. Carroll did not make it up, the sexual assault did occur, and all of Carroll’s denials were complete lies,” the attorney said.
After Trump left the court, his lawyer told the jury: “Mr. Trump believes that with his wealth and power he can do whatever he wants with Ms. Carroll without any consequences.” . Trump has criticized Carroll, calling her “sick,” “mentally ill,” and “a crappy job,” but Kaplan said, “You can’t attack her just because she feels like it.” he said.
Read the full text here.
President Trump repeats denials of allegations in real social video
In a video posted early today, President Trump reiterated his denials of the allegations against him, calling the trial a “fraud” and a “political witch hunt.”
Many of the statements in the video were things he was prohibited from saying during yesterday’s testimony. The video ended with instructions to donate to his campaign.
Judge tells Trump’s lawyer to sit after Trump leaves court
After Trump left the court midway through closing arguments, Kaplan instructed Trump’s lawyer, Boris Epshteyn, to “remain seated.”
Trump leaves court during recess
Trump left the courtroom during Carroll’s lawyer’s closing argument, and her lawyer, Roberta Kaplan, directly criticized Carroll’s actions during the trial, saying she “continued to defame her character throughout the trial.”
Mr. Kaplan recorded this event in his records.
Judges enter after a late start
The jury was convened after the defense entered the case late.
Kaplan said the jury will hear closing arguments from both sides this morning, expected to last a total of two to three hours. He said he expected the jury to be able to deliberate during lunch in the late afternoon.
Today’s proceedings got off to an eventful start.
During a tense exchange over entering some social media posts into evidence, Kaplan told Haba he was “on the verge of spending some time in captivity” and told him to “sit down.”
Kaplan tells court to refrain from speaking during closing argument
Before closing arguments, Kaplan instructed attendees to refrain from “interrupting or audible comments” during attorneys’ statements. Trump has been disciplined multiple times for speaking while other attendees were present.
Final arguments begin in Carroll damages trial against Trump
Closing arguments in Carroll’s damages case against Trump began this morning, with the former president paying far more than $10 million for repeatedly defaming her by calling the former president’s sexual abuse allegations “the work of a con man.” It is believed that he will seek more compensation.
Licap yesterday’s trial here.
Kaplan criticizes defenseman’s tardiness
Mr. Kaplan admonished the defense team for arriving late for the hearing, telling Mr. Trump’s lawyer Alina Haba that court had started 10 minutes early.
Trump arrived shortly after her and took a seat.
President Trump arrives at court
The former president arrived at the federal courthouse in Manhattan. Carol arrived about 30 minutes early.
A jury will consider how much compensation Trump should pay for defaming Carroll, and Trump is expected to appear in court for closing arguments.
Trump’s defense claims limited evidence of harm
President Trump’s lawyer Alina Haba said yesterday that contrary to The Cut’s article accusing Trump of sexual assault, it cannot be argued that Trump’s comments harmed Carroll. Ta.
Asked by Kaplan if there was insufficient evidence of causation, Haba said: “That’s right.” She pointed out that Carroll’s previous tweets were obscene and claimed that Carroll deleted the exact evidence she now relies on to support her accusations of emotional harm.
When asked by Mr. Kaplan when the takedown occurred, Mr. Haba said it happened on the day The Cut article was published. When the judge asked if there was a subpoena indicating the deletion, Judge Haba said Carroll acknowledged that.
Carol arrives at court
Carol arrived just after 8:30am. ET heard closing arguments in her trial about what damages Trump would have to pay if he defamed her. Court is scheduled to meet at 9:30 a.m. ET.
Highlights of yesterday’s Trump testimony
Trump testified for less than five minutes after clashing with a judge during the damages trial in the defamation lawsuit against Carroll.
The former president was limited in what he could say, but still insisted that Carroll’s accusations were “false.” Mr. Kaplan had already barred Mr. Trump from suing Carroll again, whether or not he sexually assaulted her, so he ordered the allegation to be struck from the record.
Asked if he stands by his claims in a 2022 deposition, in which he called her claims a “hoax” and “the work of a con man,” Trump said, “100%. Yes.” When asked if he had ever given instructions to anyone, he testified: I just wanted to protect myself, my family, and frankly, the office of the president. ” Kaplan hammered the word “no” and then ordered everything.
On cross-examination, Trump was asked if this was his first time attending a trial involving Carroll, and he answered, “Yes.”
Read the full text here.
[ad_2]
Source link
